
A commenter in my last post said she was "disturbed" by my assessment of a fellow shopper I described as possibly being a serial killer. I don't really know that on giving this person careful consideration I would really think he was a serial killer. This was actually just the exact flash of a thought that ran through my head as he first blazed past me in all his strange glory which I decided to share on my blog. My commenter thinks I am judgmental and doesn't see the value in saying the things I did. I have responded to the comment but I felt the topic deserved a whole post on its own.
I am judgmental. I make flash judgments all day long about people I don't know anything about. I make judgments all day long about people I know a lot about but since I am constantly receiving new information through my experiences with others and the world it is necessary to re-evaluate my original judgments all the time.
It is an enormous pet peeve of mine when people claim to be "nonjudgmental" as though judging people is bad. Simply making assessments of others doesn't harm them. Most of the time we make them silently in our head:
"Wow, that person has enormous breasts. I wonder if they're real?"
"That mom is so tense she is close to hurting her child."
"Don't make eye contact with that man, he is not right in the head."
If anyone tries to tell me that they don't have thoughts about others in their heads, that they don't have curiosity about people they don't know, that they never decide if they want to know someone based on how they look, they are lying. Not only to me, but to themselves. Or else they are dead.
If no one ever shared their thoughts, their judgments about others, we would be so much more alone than we already are inside. If we couldn't talk to others about the things we've observed then we have no way to build a compass against which to evaluate our own observations. Am I a complete jerk for not trusting men who live with their mothers as adults? Maybe. I don't know. What do you think? Is it a sign that someone might be a little bit off if they never make eye contact with other people or does it merely mean they are shy? I know what I think but I want to know what you think too.
How much can you tell about a person you're observing out in the world that you've never met? How fair is it to decide how you will interact (or not) before giving them a chance to show you who they are? It has nothing to do with fair and everything to do with navigating in a world full of people we have to interact with and being able to avoid bad situations because of a poor ability to make quick judgments. As the planet gets more and more crowded these skills will become more and more necessary for survival.
People judge me all the time, including myself. I am not averse to being put under the microscope. Not even yours. Go ahead: judge me. If you're not new here, you already have and keep coming back because you want to know more (which means you've decided to re-evaluate me) or you're judging me right now for the first time. Perhaps, like my commenter, you will find yourself disturbed by what you read and see here in my world.
When I was a green haired freak of a teenager I was judged openly all the time. People made all kinds of assumptions about me, some of which were true. Some not. Although I was frightened when rocks were thrown at me, I didn't ever get irate at others for trying to figure out what my deal was. We all do it. We have to.
The guy I was describing in my last post looked and behaved so strangely that in reality, he probably isn't a serial killer because supposedly
serial killers don't ever seem like serial killers.
But here's what I know about this guy I saw at the grocery store:He's got a well developed vanity, doesn't want to appear "his age", is excessively concerned with cleanliness, is uncomfortable around others, doesn't make eye contact, is almost certainly gay, would prefer not to have anything of his get too close to anything belonging to others, is not a nice customer (a no
brainer, as I saw him making his purchase), and has a lot of self discipline.
Of course, I don't just make my judgments based on a person's looks. I rely very heavily on my extra sense (I don't know that it's the sixth one, there may be more) to support the physical details. I can feel people. I have an extremely good antennae for the human spirit. It's what makes me a good writer. I see, I hear, I touch, I taste, I smell, and I sense.
And then I write about it all.
How good am I at sensing things? I'm this good:One
Cinco de Mayo in San Francisco Philip and I decided to head down to the Mission district for some burritos and thrift shopping. It's a lively area on
Cinco de Mayo since it's a largely
Latino neighborhood. We got some food and after a while we noticed that it was getting more and more crowded and rowdy. I told Philip we should catch the
Muni home. So we were waiting for our number but all of the buses were full. While waiting I started to feel a sharpening in the air, an edge in it that I couldn't place. I told Philip "It's not safe here. We really need to get out of here."
Still, all the buses were packed and it started looking like we weren't going to catch a
Muni home. The feeling of danger where we were standing became acute and urgent. I told Philip that if we couldn't squeeze our way onto the next bus we needed to just start walking. People were everywhere, pressing in. We managed to get on one and left 24
th and Mission behind us. It was an awful ride home but I knew we were lucky to have gotten on and away from where we had been.
Then next morning we saw why we needed to get away from that spot. Exactly where we had been standing, not five minutes after we left, a riot broke out and a person was stabbed to death at the corner of 24
th and Mission.
I've mentioned this story here before, but I tell it again because it's the best one I have to illustrate my point which is that if you want to survive, you must trust your gut. The women who were killed by
Ted Bundy didn't make good flash judgments about him. Everyone says he looked so ordinary, was so handsome, but if they had trained well to see inside people they would have seen something wrong. Even if they weren't sure what.
The point of discussing what we observe in the world, the point in sharing all our observations-even ones that don't seem fair or kind, is that the only way we learn about how to put our findings into the proper context is to compare our findings with those that others have made.
Furthermore, if no one ever told their stories, we'd have no books. We'd have no outlet for our imagination which takes our daily observations to another level. I've gotten in hot water for saying the wrong thing, for making someone else unhappy by saying what was on my mind, there is definitely a fine line between observing the truths of people as we see them and meanly pointing our fingers and saying things like "you should be ashamed to be who you are", a crime I rarely commit. I ask questions. I seek answers. I judge and then reevaluate because as we delve deeper into each individual we find the answers to their quirks, enlightenment sometimes, and we may often find that our flash judgments were fair based on the information we had on hand, but that when we have better more intimate information we find we were wrong about a person or a situation.
It is important to always be willing to find we've been wrong. What I don't do is make
value judgments about people based on their race, their gender, their age, or their religion (except for the ones I consider to be
cults, but that's for a different discussion altogether). I don't decide a person's worth based on any of these criteria.
Determining an opinion on the worth of a person should always be taken on with care and time.
So judge me.
If I was able to step outside myself and make observations as a stranger without any inside information I would make the following judgments:overweight, middle aged, shops at cheap clothing stores, stares at people but tries to hide it, curious, obviously listening to everything, frumpy, hairy, polite, smiles a lot-might be retarded (who smiles so much when grocery shopping?), suspicious scars on arms-possibly not a safe person, over indulges in everything, maybe used to be more fashionable,
eco-conscious, dirty nails, sloppy, probably a frazzled mom of four or five kids, not a good housekeeper.
How much of this is accurate observation? I guess you'll just have to run into me in the store to find out.